Lori Vallow trial: 5 murder defendants who pointed to unknown assailants
So-called “cult mom” Lori Vallow is set to stand trial for the October 2019 murders of her two children and her husband’s ex-wife on April 3.
Her defense team will have to address questions of an unknown killer to prove Vallow’s innocence after she was found competent to stand trial.
“It’s not unusual … to raise an alternate suspect defense,” Richard Robertson, a private investigator hired to work Vallow’s case in 2019, told Fox News Digital. “We refer to it as the SODI defense — some other dude did it.”
While many of the most prolific murder suspects and convicted killers have pleaded not guilty by reason of insanity, the following five defendants and their defense teams have pointed fingers at unknown assailants in their efforts to prove innocence.
LORI VALLOW CASE: J.J. VALLOW’S GRANDMOTHER DOESN’T ‘RECOGNIZE’ SO-CALLED ‘CULT MOM’ SMILING OUTSIDE COURT
The defense team for Lori Vallow—who allegedly killed her two children with help from her husband, Chad Daybell—does not believe she “actually participated” in the murders.
Alex Murdaugh
Alex Murdaugh, a disgraced South Carolina personal injury lawyer, was convicted on March 2 of the June 2021 murders of his wife and son.
ALEX MURDAUGH: TIMELINE OF ONCE-POWERFUL SOUTH CAROLINA LAWYER’S SPECTACULAR DOWNFALL
“I respect this court, but I’m innocent,” Murdaugh said when he took the stand in his own trial in February. “I would never under any circumstances hurt my wife Maggie, and I would never under any circumstances hurt my son, ‘Paw Paw.’”
Alex Murdaugh listens to testimony during day 25 of his double murder trial at the Colleton County Courthouse on Monday, Feb. 27, 2023. (Jeff Blake/The State/Pool)
In video evidence presented in court, Murdaugh implicated his groundskeeper in Maggie and Paul’s murders, but a jury ultimately decided that discovery presented in court was enough to sentence him to serve life in prison.
O.J. Simpson
In one of the most widely televised criminal trials in the United States, former NFL star O.J. Simpson was accused of killing his wife, Nicole Brown Simpson, and her friend Ron Goldman in 1994. He was acquitted in 1995.
OJ SIMPSON REMARKS ON ALEX MURDAUGH TRIAL: ‘I DON’T KNOW WHY THEY THINK I’M AN EXPERT ON IT’
“I did not, could not and would not have committed this crime,” Simpson said when he initially pleaded not guilty to the murders in 1995.
OJ Simpson’s 1995 case for the killing of ex-wife Nicole Brown Simpson and her friend Ron Goldman was widely televised. (VINCE BUCCI/AFP )
Part of his defense team’s strategy included evidence showing a botched crime scene, problematic DNA evidence and a pair of leather gloves found at the crime scene that his attorneys argued were worn by an unknown assailant who killed Brown Simpson and Goldman. Simpson squeezed into a new pair of gloves similar to those found at the scene during his trial.
“If it doesn’t fit, you must acquit,” his attorney, John Cochran, famously said at the time.
Scott Peterson
Scott Peterson was convicted in 2004 for the murders of his 27-year-old wife, Laci, and their unborn son, Conner. Prosecutors argued at the time that he killed Laci and disposed of her body on Christmas Eve 2002 in San Francisco Bay.
The California Supreme Court overturned Peterson’s death sentence in 2020 after news that prospective jury candidates were improperly dismissed came to light, but the court maintained his conviction.
Scott Peterson listens to Stanislaus County Deputy District attorney Dave Harris speak during a hearing at the San Mateo County Superior Court in Redwood City, California, Dec. 8, 2021. (Andy Alfaro/The Modesto Bee via AP, Pool | getty Images)
The case is far from over, according to Peterson’s lawyers, suggesting an unknown suspect killed Laci and Conner.
“Just in the last few months, we have learned new information that will prove Scott Peterson did not murder his wife, Laci,” attorney Pat Harris told Fox News Digital in a December 2022 statement. “And we are going to continue to push forward until he is freed.”
Robert Durst
Deceased New York real-estate tycoon Robert Durst was convicted in September 2021 for the murder of his best friend, Susan Berman, in 2000. He was sentenced to life in prison without parole and died in January 2022.
ROBERT DURST TESTIFIES IN LOS ANGELES MURDER TRIAL
Prior to his death, he was long suspected of killing his wife, Kathie Durst, who vanished in 1982. Prosecutors allege that the millionaire attempted to silence Berman because she helped him cover up Kathie’s disappearance.
Prosecutors share photo of Robert Durst, left, Susan Berman, middle, and Kathie Durst, right at Robert Durst’s Aug. 11 murder trial. (Fox News)
Durst took the stand in his own trial for three weeks and repeatedly testified that he did not know who killed Berman.
He did admit under cross-examination, however, that he would lie under oath in order to get out of trouble.
“‘Did you kill Susan Berman?’ is strictly a hypothetical,” Durst said from the stand. “I did not kill Susan Berman. But if I had, I would lie about it.”
Lori Vallow and Chad Daybell
Both Vallow and her husband are accused of killing 17-year-old Tylee Vallow and 7-year-old J.J. Vallow in 2019.
They were initially scheduled to stand a joint trial in 2021, but proceedings have been delayed due to Vallow’s competency examinations and an “exceptionally voluminous” collection of evidence, among other factors. Judge Steven Boyce ruled in February that their cases would be severed because Vallow has refused to waive her right to a speedy trial.
An Idaho judge has blocked Lori Vallow’s request for a meeting with her husband, Chad Daybell, left. (Madison County Jail)
Their defense teams are expected to argue that the couple did not kill their children, suggesting that an outside party did. Additionally, while the couple has not blamed one another for the crimes, Robertson says it is not out of the question.
“What I don’t know is whether Chad is going to be testifying [in Vallow’s trial]. … He’s in a great position to cooperate against Lori,” the private investigator explained.
LORI VALLOW DEBUTS NEW JAIL LOOK AS DEFENSE CLAIMS SHE DIDN’T ‘PARTICIPATE’ IN CHILDREN’S MURDERS
Authorities arrested Vallow in February 2020 and Daybell in June 2020.
Lori and Chad Daybell are accused of killing 17-year-old Tylee Ryan, right, and 7-year-old J.J. Vallow in 2019. (Rexberg Police Department)
The Fremont County grand jury initially issued indictments against Vallow and Daybell in May 2021 on two counts of first-degree murder in connection with Tylee and J.J.’s deaths. The two children disappeared in September 2019.
They were missing for months when police say the couple lied about the childrens’ whereabouts and then slipped away to Hawaii before the childrens’ bodies were found in 2020 buried on Daybell’s property in rural Idaho.
Vallow and Daybell, who married in November 2019, allegedly collected J.J.’s and Tylee’s Social Security benefits between Oct. 1, 2019, and Jan. 22, 2020, after their murders.
Lori Vallow Daybell, 49, right, and her most recent husband, Chad Daybell, 54, are accused of killing two of Vallow Daybell’s two children and collecting Social Security benefits in their names after their deaths. In a recent court filing, Vallow claims she was not present when they died. (Tony Blakeslee/East Idaho News)
CLICK HERE TO GET THE FOX NEWS APP
The couple were indicted in late May 2021 on multiple counts each of conspiracy to commit first-degree murder and grand theft by deception, first-degree murder and conspiracy to commit first-degree murder related to the deaths of Tylee, J.J. and Chad Daybell’s ex-wife, officials announced at the time. Arizona officials in June 2021 also indicted Vallow in the July 2019 murder of her ex-husband, Charles Vallow.
Daybell has written several apocalyptic novels based loosely on Mormon theology. Both were involved in a group that promotes preparedness for the biblical end times. Vallow and Daybell bonded over their religious beliefs after initially meeting in 2018, when they appeared together for the first time on a podcast discussing theories about the end of the world.
The Associated Press contributed to this report.
